POLL: Would you support a temporary work visa for illegal aliens?

Lou Dobbs ^ | 12/25/03

[4.1O dana super trac pak]

Would you support a temporary work visa for illegal aliens?

[gcruse]

I find your scriptural references bigoted and false

LOL  It's heck being blown out of the water, ain't it?

[raybbr]

Those who just hate illegals are irrational. We cannot function without them. If you think otherwise you are just completely uninformed. Go to the factories and jobsites and take a good long look. Step back in the kitchen of nearly every restaurant. Look at your gardener.

If this totally inane statement were true, then how did we become the greatest industrial nation on earth before all these wonderful illegals came here?

[Pa' fuera]

I'm not advocating mass influx of illegals. I'm advocating a controlled foolproof guest-worker program.

well, judging by the way the government tracks and deports illegal aliens now, I'd say there was no way you're going to get the controlled, foolproof guest-worker program. Any guest worker program will result in a mass influx of illegals, that's why there shouldn't be one until the government can prove to us that it can control who enters the country and deport people who should be deported.

[packrat35]

You are just not rational. Illegal aliens are benefitting almost no one, as their costs in social services alone costs us much more than they ever put back into society.

There are plenty of Americans to work the low cost jobs-they are called TEENAGERS.

Many now do not work cause they are replaced by adult illegal aliens. Many do not work because we give out FOR FREE too much oney or nothing.

I work in a warehouse that is easily close to 1/2 illegal Mexican-in Memphis, no less. Do you really believe there are no Americans to do this work. It pays better than minimum wage, however our pay and raises are now dropping as they hire more and more low wage ILLEGALS.

Furthermore, they don't want to assimilate into US society. They expect me to learn Spainish for them. UNFRICKING BELIEVABLE!!! This is the middle part of America here.

[Dan Evans]

LOL Be prepared for a WOG flood, then.

At least they speak English.

Anglo-saxon Brits live in the UK because they want to.

But after the EU tentacles reach out they may have second thoughts. The rich ones will come first.

[Pa' fuera]

Furthermore, they don't want to assimilate into US society. They expect me to learn Spainish for them. UNFRICKING BELIEVABLE!!! This is the middle part of America here.

Hey, wait, I thought we stole Tennessee from Mexico in 1848. That's what Mexicans and the PC crowd would have us believe.

They're just taking it back, along with all the improvements.

[PistolPaknMama]

voted and bumped! thanks!

[At _War_With_Liberals]

"We all benefit from thier cheap labor and we have forced them into a slave labor condition and we treat them inhumanely. "

Knock off the "WE" crap. YOU/YOUR BUSINESS benefits and YOU let them work for you under inhumane conditions.

'They' do not do anything for me, and I do not hire/run companies that exploit them, pay no taxes and benefits, and USE them as slave labor like YOU do.

Your attitude is disgusting. And YOU call FR a 'hate site'?

Your assertion that all illegal Mexicans are pathetic slaves is racist on its face. "Mexicans serve as MERCY's slaves, so out of wealthy guilt, we must reward them and screw the lower classes here".

[Dan Evans]

OK. You go live in a mud-hut South of the border

No American is going to go live in a mud hut. A lot of us would however like to send the US army south of the border and solve the problem by kicking out that corrupt government.

[onyx]

NO: 1773

YES: 762

[Dan Evans]

Nice work Nea, I'm impressed.

[txdoda]

If you live in the Rio Grande area I can understand your feelings. I would move if I were you.>>>>>>>

UNFRICKING BELIEVABLE......*mercy*

You go on & on about *how great* the illegals are, and *how much* we need them, and how we should *support them*, and then *your advice* to a US TAXPAYING CITIZEN, that (might) live in a heavily INVADED AREA.......is to MOVE ???

HELLO, we've got AT LEAST a million citizens living along the Rio Grande in TX, you think they should all MOVE to accommodate the illegals you support ??? You think ALL citizens on the southern border should MOVE. ???

*If* your an American, you truly disgust me !!

[B4Ranch]

Would you please address the rest of my #63 post.

[fightu4it]

"Those who just hate illegals are irrational. We cannot function without them. If you think otherwise you are just completely uninformed. Go to the factories and jobsites and take a good long look. Step back in the kitchen of nearly every restaurant. Look at your gardener."

Those who just hate criminals are irrational. We cannot function without them. If you think otherwise you are just completely uninformed. Go to the factories and jobsites and take a good long look. Step back in the kitchen of nearly every resturant. Look at your gardener.

Those who just hate liberals............... well, you get the picture.

[mercy]

Never ceases to amaze me how ready folks are on this site to put words in others mouths. Try reading my posts instead of making them up FOR me. I think I have been pretty clear.

You are so full of hate you make no sense.

As to my commentsw about leaving the S. Texas area I meant that since she hates Mexicans so much she should get out of there. They aren't going anywhere anytime soon.

And to the other liar who thinks I employ Mexicans .... I do not sir and you are crude boor.

[winker]

WELCOME REAL WORLD Patriot! Stick to your guns. This problem is just like the Animal Control Problem; Get em licenced and Registered and Finger/Paw printed! Sack em, Tag em, and Bag em otherwise!

[mercy]

I think that somewhere in my twenty or so replys I have.

I advocate a simple program involving foolproof IDs and tough criminal enforcement. No loopholes. All the people arguing with me offer nothing except the unrealistic idea that we are going to use the military and stop all illegals. Never happen. Can't catch up to the 8 or 12 million here now.

What do you people want? Genocide? You ARE haters. You are seathing with it. You call me a liberal because I believe there must be a realistic way to solve this age old problem. You have no answers ... only childidh hate-filled rhetoric.

You call me a liberal. Ok ... effing Nazis! Makes a lot of sense doesn't it? I swear ... the mental IQ around here is getting lower and lower.

[jwalsh07]

No, I don't support work visas for illegal aliens however I would support temporary work visas legally obtained.

[4.1O dana super trac pak]

"Our economy needs their labor..."

"We cannot function without them..."

Links, sources, proof?

Take your time.

[4.1O dana super trac pak]

I just checked cis.org, actually it is "only" 36% of legal Mexican immigrants, the HS dropout rate is close to 70%, so this is sure to boost that number soon.