AP: U.S.-Mexico Border Patrol Failing

AP ^ | 11/02/03 | NIKO PRICE

[Pikamax]

Nov 2, 3:42 PM (ET)

By NIKO PRICE

(AP) Jose Porras, a migrant from the Mexican state of Guanajuato, stands next to a coffin shaped alter... Full Image

SASABE, Mexico (AP) - A crackdown along the U.S.-Mexico border designed to prevent terrorists from entering the United States hasn't stopped even one known militant from slipping into America since Sept. 11, an Associated Press investigation has found.

Instead, the tightening net of Border Patrol and Immigration agents has slowed trade, snarled traffic and cost American taxpayers millions, perhaps billions, of dollars, while hundreds of migrants have died trying to evade the growing army of border authorities.

"If there are concerns about the border in national security terms, they are misplaced," said Claudia Smith, a migration activist who directs the California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation.

Sept. 11, 2001, was a defining moment in the politics of illegal immigration. The terrorist attacks abruptly halted major reforms designed to legalize much of the flow of workers heading north from Mexico. The reforms had won support from President Bush - a former Texas governor - and members of the U.S. Congress.

After more than 3,000 people died in the al-Qaida strikes on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, the Bush administration told Mexican officials they were concerned that easing migration restrictions could lead to another terrorist attack.

Instead of opening the border, the United States closed it further. Bush invested heavily in border protection, budgeting $9 billion for the fiscal year that began this Oct. 1, a $400 million increase over the previous year. The government was unable to provide budget figures for earlier years.

The number of Border Patrol agents assigned to the southern border rose from 8,500 in 2000 to at least 9,500 today. Staffing along the Mexican border for the immigration, customs and agriculture departments, which monitor legal crossing points, grew from 4,371 in fiscal 2001 to 4,873 in the fiscal year that just ended.

New technology gives Border Patrol agents state-of-the-art helicopters to search for migrants from the air and a new generation of ground sensors and remote video systems to track them on the ground.

"We have become much more vigilant than we were just a couple of years ago, without a doubt," said Border Patrol spokesman Mario Villarreal.

Despite the crackdown, an AP investigation involving interviews with dozens of officials, immigration activists and migrants in Mexico, California, Arizona and Washington, turned up no evidence that any suspected terrorist has been prevented from coming to America.

Mauricio Juarez, a spokesman for the Mexican government's National Migration Institute, told AP that Mexico hasn't arrested a single terrorist suspect headed north. And he said the United States hasn't informed Mexico of any arrested on the U.S. side - something it presumably would do.

Spokesmen for the U.S. Border Patrol, the FBI and Immigration and Customs Enforcement say national security guidelines prevent them from saying whether any suspected terrorists have been arrested trying to cross the border from Mexico.

Robert Bonner, commissioner of the Bureau of Customs and Border Protection, said "hundreds of people per year from ... high interest countries, such as Pakistan" are turned back at legal border crossings from Mexico, but he didn't give any indication any of them were terrorists.

Several Border Patrol agents along the Arizona-Mexico line said that although they have become increasingly vigilant toward the possibility of terrorists using established people-smuggling routes, they have found none.

"The people who are coming across this border are people who can only pay $1,500 to a smuggler. A terrorist can pay $30,000 or $40,000 and go to the northern border where we don't have the resources to stop them," said agent Matt Roggow.

He navigated his Humvee across ranchers' dirt roads in the hilly desert near Tucson, leaning out the window to "cut sign": search for footprints in the soft dirt that betray the paths of desperate migrants through the vast desert. He knows well how difficult the trip is.

"I'd be willing to bet that a terrorist isn't going to take the chance of coming across this border," he said.

Up north, the Border Patrol has dramatically increased its staffing since Sept. 11, in part in response to incidents like the 1999 arrest of Ahmed Ressam, who was convicted of plotting to bomb Los Angeles International Airport during millennium celebrations.

But migration activists note that the Sept. 11 hijackers entered the United States on visas, not by sneaking across any border.

People-smugglers say that occasional groups of Chinese and Russian migrants pass through Mexico on their way north, but that the bulk of migrants are Mexicans and Central Americans headed for jobs that - because of low pay or dangerous conditions - Americans don't want.

As for terrorists, they say none would even think of crossing from Mexico.

"They have visas. They fly in," says Victor Saravia, a Tijuana-based people-smuggler since 1970, wearing a baseball cap and a denim shirt embroidered with the words "U.S. Navy."

"Illegals have nothing to do with terrorism," he said.

The fallout from terrorism fears, however, has wreaked havoc with border life.

Border crossings have become snarled in traffic, often with hours-long waits for Mexicans commuting to jobs or Americans heading across the border to shop.

Trade has slowed as well, with stricter checks for trucks carrying merchandise across the border, especially when the U.S. terror alert is raised to orange. That has happened four times since the terror-alert system was introduced in March 2002.

"When the level is raised above yellow, it is much slower. They stop every car, every truck. It becomes a hurdle for business," said Maria Luisa O'Connell, general director of the nonprofit, Phoenix-based Border Trade Alliance.

Migrants - increasingly babies and children - have been pushed into even more remote desert crossings, where they face bandits, snakes, dehydration and heat exposure. Since October 2001, at least 742 Mexicans - and many more of other nationalities - have died making the trip.

The movement to remote desert areas, mainly in Arizona, began a decade ago, when the United States cracked down on illegal migration around the major cities, and it intensified with the increased vigilance after Sept. 11.

Illegal migration dropped off significantly in the weeks after the terrorist attacks. It has since rebounded. While the number of detentions by the Border Patrol has dropped steadily since Sept. 11, the number of deaths has not.

Figures are incomplete, since the Border Patrol counts only deaths reported to it along a narrow strip near the border, and the Mexican government counts only the deaths of Mexicans.

The Border Patrol reported 320 migrants died from Oct. 1, 2001, to Sept. 30, 2002, and 340 in the fiscal year ending last month. From Oct. 1, 2000, to Sept. 30, 2001, it counted 336 deaths.

The Mexican government counted 371 for the 2002 calendar year, and another 371 so far this year.

Those numbers are higher because they include deaths that occur farther from the border, such as the 19 migrants found in a locked truck in Victoria, Texas, this year, or the 11 found dead in a rail car in Iowa last year. But they don't include non-Mexicans who die making the trip.

While the Border Patrol says the fewer apprehensions indicate slowing migration, the number of illegal migrants in the United States doesn't appear to be dropping.

Victor Clark, a Tijuana anthropologist who studies migration, said that if illegal migrants weren't getting in, there would be a severe labor shortage in farms along the U.S. West Coast, where Mexican migrants make up much of the labor force. There isn't.

In fact, some figures indicate the number of illegal immigrants may be rising. The money Mexicans send home from the United States, often used as an indicator of Mexican migration to the north, reached a record $12 billion this year, compared with $10 billion last year.

And across the border, migrants say as long as the job markets in the two countries remain unequal, the flow of people will continue no matter how hard anyone tries to stop it.

"It's all about the money," said Zenon Hernandez, 35, jealously watching a pigeon fly across the fence separating Tijuana, Mexico, from San Ysidro, Calif. "We have to keep fighting to get across, however many times it takes."

---

Niko Price is correspondent-at-large for The Associated Press.

[RnMomof7]

Mauricio Juarez, a spokesman for the Mexican government's National Migration Institute, told AP that Mexico hasn't arrested a single terrorist suspect headed north. And he said the United States hasn't informed Mexico of any arrested on the U.S. side - something it presumably would do.

A bag of potato chips and a can of soda and the Mexican policia will look the other way

The fact is the Border Patrol is working with their hands tied behind their backs . They are restricted where they can go and how far they can chase..many have been put in stationary positions ..as if the mexicans would not figure that out.

The truth is that the government is not interested in stopping the flow. Their goal is to make life so miserable on the border that Americans will beg for "open borders"

[DumpsterDiver]

there is no border patrol when one million illegals enter the usa in one year...

Your post is disgustingly accurate.

[calawah98]

It is not only Calif, but it is affecting the eastern states also. The western states are turning into little Mexico, so crap like in the article makes my blood boil.
Just got thro at numbers resending more faxes to President Bush, NO AMENSTY.

[Happy2BMe]

Whaaa? We got borders??

The Census Bureau said that about 52 percent of the U.S. foreign-born population is from Latin America, 27 percent from Asia and 15 percent from Europe

Study: Immigration Biggest Contributor to Sprawl (87% of Growth Attributed to Immigrants)

We ain't got no laws, neither!

---

From El Plan Espiritual de Aztlan A nation autonomous and free - culturally, socially, economically, and politically- will make its own decisions on the usage of our lands, the taxation of our goods, the utilization of our bodies for war, the determination of justice (reward and punishment), and the profit of our sweat.
El Plan de Aztlan is the plan of liberation!

Aztlan Flyer

Common Cause

[Happy2BMe]

"

This should be in breaking news...

...about 25 years ago."

Dear friend . . it WAS!

The story ended with the truth - it's all about MONEY.

If our corrupt polititians handn't allowed our corrupt businesses to work clandestinely with their corrupt Mexican counterparts, do you think any of this would have happened?

[janetgreen]

NO AMNESTY

Hi calawah, I'm in complete agreement, because as you know, I live in Mexifornia, the formerly beautiful state of California. I wish some of the others who think that illegal immigration isn't a problem would visit southern California and take a good look around. Maybe they would like to help pay the bills for these freeloaders.

[Klickitat]

""It's all about the money," said Zenon Hernandez"

We know.

[TLI]

Americans told George NO to the illegals.

George decides to ignore the Americans.

Americans tell George NO to reelection.

George begins to understand the concept of N + O.

[c-b 1]

The truth is that the government is not interested in stopping the flow. Their goal is to make life so miserable on the border that Americans will beg for "open borders"

That's a fact!

[RnMomof7]

Ping!!

BTTT

[calawah98]

What alternative do we have?

[TLI]

What alternative do we have?

AHHHHH! Interesting question. There may not be any alternatives to GW (that would be acceptable) or, for that matter, preferable to one of the currently proposed dem candidates... or suicide.

There are alternatives to thinking there is nothing that can be done.

When the fed fails to act on the needs of The People, then to hell with the fed, we can do it ourselves. There are a few prerequisites that MUST be adhered too, and a few things that are just going to have to be accepted.

I am at work right now, but I will generate a more in depth response and post.....