To: Roscoe
Find a single authority or court decision Your criterion for deciding constitutionality is invalid, as even you realize when the subject is Roe v Wade.
148 posted on
10/08/2002 1:48:44 PM PDT by
MrLeRoy
To: MrLeRoy
Really? Rehnquist wrote a superb dissent.
150 posted on
10/08/2002 1:52:45 PM PDT by
Roscoe
To: MrLeRoy
"Your criterion for deciding constitutionality is invalid, as even you realize when the subject is Roe v Wade." - MrLR
_________________________________
Exactly. - Notice how roscoe could not counter my reasoning here:
Posted by tpaine to Roscoe
On News/Activism Oct 8 12:55 PM #126 of 148
"Roe v. Wade invented a "Constitional right" to commit abortions out of thin air." - roscoe
Not at all. R-v-W, in effect, told states to obey the 14th amendment in the writing of abortion law.
Outright prohibition of abortion was declared unconstitutional for a number of specified reasons. - Read it.
154 posted on
10/08/2002 1:56:48 PM PDT by
tpaine
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson