[Congressman Billybob]

You, sir or madame, are a moron.

Based on the political background of the judge in question, and her prior decisions, and the facr that Wilson's appointment by Clinton (him) expired in November, 2001, it should be clear that this judge twisted the law to reach a preconceived decision.

This will be reversed on appeal. You can then come back to FreeRepublic and apologize for your ludicrous posts claiming that this was a correct decision and saying "I told you so."

I told YOU, so.

Congressman Billybob

Phil & Billybob in the mornings.

[VRWC_minion]

You, sir or madame, are a moron.

I may be a moron or maybe just a maroon, but the original thought on FR was that Berry had no case.

I then looked at the history of this law and its not at all clear that she had no case. Its about 50/50. I went further and said that because liberals will tend to rule on the outcome and that conservatives will tend to rule according to strict construction then the most likely outcome will be that Berry's interpretation will stand. After that either Bush and congress proceed with mass resignations to pack the commission or congress rights a remedy.

You may want to go back and read some of the previous discussions on this here on FR and you can see the development of the discussion and research. I think connectthedots was part of those original threads and he has captured the ideas well in his posts on this thread.