Skip to comments.The Grunion mystery, solved at last
Posted on 08/27/2019 10:49:11 AM PDT by robowombat
The Grunion mystery, solved at last Matt Grills | The American Legion MAR 19, 2010
Nearly three years after USS Grunion (SS 216) was found off the Aleutian Islands, Bruce Abele continues to puzzle over what sank his fathers submarine in the early days of World War II.
In 2006, Abele and his two younger brothers, John and Brad, made headlines when an ocean-surveying firm they hired to scan the floor of the Bering Sea sent them an image of an oblong object with features resembling a conning tower and periscope mast.
The next summer, a remotely operated vehicle (ROV) confirmed the object as the wreckage of a U.S. submarine. At last, the Abele boys had solved the decades-old mystery of what happened to their father, Lt. Cmdr. Mannert Abele and his 69-man crew.
Since then, experts have poured over photos and video footage of the discovery, theorizing about what caused Grunions loss on July 30, 1942. Clearly the submarine went below crush depth and imploded; a channel left from its descent down an underwater slope is visible in photos.
The rear dive plane is clearly in dive position, and that tells us they lost depth control, says Bruce Abele, 80.
But why? An account by a Japanese officer aboard the freighter Kano Maru claims that after being torpedoed by a submarine north of Kiska, Alaska, the crew saw ripples in the water, fired their deck guns and hit its conning tower.
We originally thought a 3-inch shell had hit the shears, the supports that hold the periscope, Bruce says. Recently, though, we met Cmdr. Charlie Tate, who did eight war patrols on Gato, a sister ship of Grunion. He told us the damage to the shears was almost certainly not caused by a 3-inch shell, but by something larger. Right now the hypothesis we are leaning toward is that it was a circular torpedo that did not explode.
If thats the case, Kano Maru actually shot at a washing wave caused by the bubble that rose to the surface when Grunion imploded. A jammed rear dive plane combined with a disruption would have left the submarine unable to blow its forward ballast tanks and falling fast.
In August 1942, the Navy recognized Grunion as missing. The Abeles never even got to say goodbye to their father, whom everyone, even his sons, affectionately called Jim. He took them to lunch at the Officers Club at the submarine base in Groton, Conn., before saying he had work to do. That work was a classified mission in the North Pacific.
We didnt see him a great deal because he was always at sea, Bruce says. Even when he was lost, and we didnt hear about that until Sept. 30, 1942, it was kind of almost a paperwork thing. But as time went on it had an impact.
As the years passed, Brad Abele started compiling what the brothers call The Jim Book. When Grunion disappeared, Bruce was 12, Brad was 9 and John was 5. Originally written for family and friends, The Jim Book describes the Abeles memories of their father a Naval Academy graduate who loved soccer and what it was like growing up without him.
The book also includes notes from students who learned under Abele at NROTC at Harvard. One of them, Endicott Chub Peabody, was an All-American defensive lineman on the football team who went on to become governor of Massachusetts. Peabody credited Abele with inspiring him to serve on submarines.
More and more, The Jim Book fueled the Abeles curiosity. What exactly had happened to their father?
The story that would become their groundbreaking quest to find Grunion began in 1998, when Air Force Lt. Col. Richard Lane paid a dollar for a wiring diagram of a winch from Kano Maru at an antiques store in Denver. Hoping to learn more about the ship, he posted a query online in 2001. A Japanese historian and translator named Yutaka Iwasaki replied, saying the diagram was indeed authentic and that he also thought he knew what happened to USS Grunion. Iwasaki had discovered and translated an old article published in a 1960s Japanese maritime journal by a naval officer who served aboard Kano Maru, describing the ships battle with a submarine near Kiska.
Lane contacted Commander, Submarine Force, U.S. Pacific Fleet (COMSUBPAC), which had a Web site dedicated to Grunion. There, he posted Iwasakis information.
Meanwhile, Bruces sons fiancОe shared a copy of The Jim Book with her boss, a World War II history buff, who sent Abele a list of Grunion-related Web sites. Id seen them before and I almost didnt take a look, he says. Then I saw the post from Yutaka Iwasaki saying he thinks he knows what happened to Grunion and, most important, a rough idea of where it was. That was huge.
The Abeles searched for Iwasakis e-mail address, and after a string of 70 messages, John found one from Iwasaki. He sent a message asking if he was the one who knew something about Grunion. Finally, a reply arrived: It is me. I have prayed for repose for your fathers soul.
Armed with knowledge of the submarines approximate location, the brothers became serious about finding the submarine. John Abele, who founded Boston Scientific, the global manufacturer and marketer of medical devices, suggested bringing in Robert Ballard of Titanic fame.
Though Ballard declined to join them, he gave us a kindergarten course in finding a sub, Bruce says: start with sidescan sonar, which can cover a swath width of two or three miles at a time, then send down an ROV.
In August 2006, the Abeles hired Williamson & Associates of Seattle to conduct sonar scans off the Aleutians, spanning an area about 250 square miles. An Alaskan crabbing boat, the Aquila, ferried the equipment.
They were sending us e-mails every day, and I was getting up at 2 oclock in the morning to see what was going on, Bruce says.
A week into the search, scans detected a long, narrow silhouette 3,200 feet deep. Though 20 feet shorter than Grunion, the object appeared to have a curious appendage resembling propeller guards found on submarines of that type.
Just before the expedition, Iwasaki contacted the Abeles, saying hed visited Japans military archives and found a chart listing the exact coordinates of the submarine. It was almost right on the money, Bruce says.
Certain theyd found what they were looking for, the brothers sent Aquila back a year later, this time with an ROV. Almost right away, it returned images of a badly damaged submarine: a 50-foot section of its bow missing, exposed pipes and hoses, interior bunks and a dive wheel, an aft battery hatch blown wide open. With water pressure at 1,300 pounds per square inch, Grunion imploded.
Theres no question about what happened, Bruce says.
The submarines discovery prompted a search for the families of Grunions crew. For that task, the Abeles had round-the-clock help from three women they call the sub ladies: Mary Bentz of Bethesda, Md., Vickie Rodgers of Mayfield, Ky., and Rhonda Raye of Cartersville, Ga.
Bentz lost her uncle, Carmine Parziale, on Grunion. Rodgers great uncle, Merritt Graham, went down too, along with Rayes great-uncle, Paul Edward Banes. Together the women spent two years tracking down every one of Grunions 70 families.
They scoured genealogy files, phone books, marriage records and newspaper obituaries. On the same day the submarines wreckage was found by the ROV, Bentz went on a Detroit talk-radio show to ask for information on anyone who might know relatives of Seaman Byron Traviss of Michigan, the only family she hadnt located. Amazingly, the wife of Traviss cousin heard the broadcast and called in.
"She said, 'I have his Purple Heart hanging on my dining-room wall,'" Bentz says.
The sub ladies also consulted a large volume of letters from Mannert Abeles wife to families of the Grunion crew.
My mother was extremely disciplined, Bruce says. After we got notification of Grunions loss, she handwrote a condolence note to every one of the next of kin, and then when Jim got the Navy Cross, she wrote a second note. We have three large loose-leaf notebooks all organized by crewmember with all the correspondence that went back and forth. You cannot read that stuff with a dry eye. Its just incredible.
With Grunion's families located, Bentz went to work calling the hometown newspapers of each crewman, asking for an article or obituary.
"My focus right now is to have them honored in every possible place," including the World War II Registry, the Navy Memorial and the National Purple Heart Hall of Honor in New York, she says.
Sadly, Brad Abele died in 2008, a few months before 200 relatives of the Grunion crew including two sailors widows gathered for a memorial service aboard USS Cod in Cleveland.
As the crews names were read, Grunions own bell tolled. Removed before battle because of its weight, the bell laid in a scrap heap at Pearl Harbor until the 1950s, when a chaplain asked if he could keep it. He took it home to Greenville, Miss., and later donated it to the citys visitors center. As it happens, a Grunion crewman, Edward Knowles, came from Greenville. His sister, Geraldine Kendrick, told Bruce about the bell, and arrangements were made to borrow it for the memorial.
The story of Grunions discovery is filled with such coincidences, he says.
Theres also been healing. Before its own sinking, Grunion sunk two Japanese sub chasers. Iwasaki found the widow of one of those sub chasers commanders, now 99, and the Abeles sent her pressed flowers from Kiska, the island just south of the confrontation. With appreciation, she sent a hand-woven gift to "the sons of Catherine E. Abele."
Questions still surround what exactly transpired aboard Grunion before it sank, but at last the grave site of its crew is known.
That obviously means a lot to us, Bruce says. But it also means a lot to so many families.
Matt Grills is managing editor of The American Legion Magazine.
Sunk by her own torpedo.
Fired four at a Japanese destroyer. One ran low, two bounced off without exploding. The fourth circled back and took of her periscope.
(According to Wikipedia)
Robowombat - Thank you for posting this article about finding the wreck of the WW2 US submarine Grunion.
In memory of those who sail beneath the sea.
And see this article robowombat also posted with photographs of the wreck of the USS Grunion:
US Navy torpedos were super bad through about the first half of WWII, or even longer.
Many problems, and the Navy brass refused to believe numerous reports of malfunctions and misfires from captains in the fleet. Navy thought they weren’t trying hard enough.
Among other things, they had a tendency to cruse deeper than the depth they were set for, thereby missing targets by shooting underneath them. But that wasn’t the only problem.
Thank you for the ping and links. Much appreciated
US torpedoes were very prone to malfunction of hitting their targets and not exploding or running wild and the technical problems were not solved till 1944....Japanese torpedoes were the best in the world.
Japanese surface action tactics were built around their torpedoes not their guns!
That was because the IJN was willing to expend lots of torpedo’s in test firings at various size target hulks, different ranges etc. to perfect the weapon. The U.S.,on the other hand, was very reluctant to waste expensive torpedoes for testing.
The poorly-written article raised more questions, so I ultimately found this
I “NEVER” reference wikiliberal.
Legendary Commander Charles B. Swede Momsen is credited for fighting the true enemy at home those years: Bureaucracy.
Some things never change.
EVERY WW2 movie always indicates successful torpedoes .... some miss, but the ones that hit explode.
Why did we name a U.S. Navy sub after a fish that beaches itself to spawn and deliver its eggs?
“On Eternal Patrol”
We were building a LOT of submarines, and they all had to be named after some type of fish.
That was the Navy scheme for naming ships in those days.
Battleships after states, hence West Virginia, Iowa, Heavy cruisers after large cities such as Los Angeles, Baltimore, subs after fish, Tang, Tautog, Grunion. Aircraft carriers were originally named after Revolutionary war ships or battles such as Yorktown, Saratoga, Bonhomme Richard.
Each of the many types of ships in the Navy had their own naming criteria.
As a. Kid i went with my folks up to Ventura County in the middle of the night and captured a 5 gallon bucket full
Back then you could drink beer, have bonfires and sleep on the beach
Certain it is not that way today
Even back then the LA. County sheriffs were no fun
What an incredible story of collecting from all across the nation and even part of the world. Remarkable that one son had the resources to mount such an expedition.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.