We were (at lest I was) discussing the instances where God would elect someone in a culture where he remained ignorant of the Word. A native on an unknown island that has had no contact with the outside.
The fact that God reveals Himself through the Bible has little impact where there are no Bibles, right?
Your position, it seems, is that God will not elect anyone in a culture without a chance to read the Bible. I happen to think God can elect whomever He wants.
SD