[St.Chuck]

I'm always impressed by Stephen Hand's comprehensive understanding of matters and his ability to articulate them. Not only does he explain the circumstances around the "kiss", but he delves accurately into the minds of those claim to be so shocked and awed. Good post. Thanks.

[NYer]

Good post. Thanks

Thank you for stopping by and commenting on Hand's article. As is often the case in the forum, the usual dissidents just had to spew their venom. Your comments are appreciated.

[drstevej]

Would you like to see the Pope make this a regular practice? How about a papal Holy Books of the world kissing tour?

Or is this an attempt at rationalizing an embarassing situation.

I have no history of bashing JPII on FR, but this event should not be reationalized. It was a mistake and it's wiser to admit it rather than try to justify it as noble. Popes don't need to be perfect. Why not acknowledge that this was a bad decision and a bad example? And then move on...