I thank God for Michael Rose and his book. Personally, I believe most of what he wrote, but there are a few facts that may be incorrect or at least partially true and partially false. I'm thinking of the "MTV" priest down in Rhode Island and also the stuff about Mr. Kellyani (sp) - Mr. Rose should probably clean those things up with a preface in any new editions.
His book was timely and informative and eye-opening and a lot of respected, orthodox, "in the know" Catholics endorse it, good enough for me! The back and forth stuff I read at least every other week in magazines and blogs drives me nuts. I'm not sure what it accomplishes.