[Catholicguy]

Everyone therefore has the right to examine what he feels able to accept..." Davies is a very dangerous man. He plays both sides of the schismatic fence and he is now, tragically, the president of Una Voce. Any Catholic with a rudimentary knowledge of Catholicsm KNOWS a Catholic does not have liberty to (Everyone therefore has the right to examine what he feels able to accept...") decide whether or not to reject or accept, in part or in whole, an Ecumenical Council. Good grief.

Keep flirting with the schismatics and your brain will completely rot.<>

[Tantumergo]

Catholicguy - I don't know whether it was Davies or which traditionalist in particular wrote this quote:

"Taking conciliar custom into consideration and also the pastoral purpose of Vatican II, the Council defined as binding on the Church only those things in matters of faith and morals which it openly declared to be binding."

But do you really think that holding these opinions would lead to schismatic tendencies? Surely you are not suggesting that every word of Vatican II is binding on us??