Posted on 10/09/2025 7:27:22 AM PDT by CondoleezzaProtege
“Wherever dispensationalism has gained ground, Christian culture has lost ground.”
Although the claim that dispensationalism has hurt the church is not new, it was interesting to see how much agreement the post garnered in the comments. Some commenters labeled dispensationalism as the worst heresy the church has seen. Others said dispensationalism is a damnable heresy which has single-handedly lost the American culture war. In this post I would like to analyze the argument that dispensationalism itself is dangerous and responsible for the cultural loss we see in Western culture today…
Setting aside exegetical and interpretive arguments about Scripture for a moment, how would one prove or disprove the above argumentation? Perhaps we could look at other countries, like the UK or Germany, which have very limited dispensational influence, and compare them to America. Both the UK and Germany have robust Christian histories, yet both have secularized dramatically without the alleged dastardly influence of dispensational theology.
Rather than comparing dispensational and non-dispensational countries, we could just analyze the moral shifts in America itself.
…Because dispensationalists “know” the world is going to get worse anyway, they are said to embrace shallow Christianity, only focusing on “getting people saved” without seeing any need for growth or fortitude. According to this characterization, depth of conviction and discipleship have little value to the dispensationalist since the church will be removed from the world soon.
Thus, dispensationalists either don’t care about the culture, or else are motivated to focus elsewhere because they believe they are fighting an unwinnable war…
(Excerpt) Read more at petergoeman.com ...
that the Old Testament must be interpreted within its own context.
there is a distinction between Israel and the Church.
there is a future for ethnic Israel.
that the promises made to ethnic Israel will have a literal, future fulfillment in the Millennial Kingdom.
Dispensationalism itself doesn’t hurt the church. But what does hurt the church is arguing over dispensationalism more than teaching people to stick to the Lord like glue in this ever increasing hedonistic world that needs to hear Jesus and see us be real enough to live it like we mean it.
All these statements line up with scripture. Not seeing a problem.
What hurts the Church is many do not teach the truth and muddle the message of Christ’s love and what a Sinful life will get you...They fear it will burn People’s ears with the truth and many People today do not like the truth...
No. It gives hope. Replacement theology is wrong and breeds division, preterism and anti semitism. Church of Thyatira and Sardis.
In today’s World the day the Church is Raptured out before Christ’s return many Churches will not notice a noticeable drop in attendance as most Churches are like the Church of Laodicea.
Since Hebrew thought is circular. What happens today will repeat in its season. “Dispensationalism’ is incompatible with the Bible. A clearer view would use cycles of seven. So, the question should be, where are we in that cycle of seven, and when does it end.
The opposite is historically true.
Indeed but as non-baby boomer millennial, I see that the dispensational hype of recent decades has produced rotten fruit within the American church complex and a toxic cultural psyche overall…It provides a horrible basis for leaving a lasting legacy of faith and cultural renewal.
Replacement Theology does not breed "anti-Semitism" (i.e., hatred of Jews because of their race). Christians who follow RT have no hatred for the Apostles, nor for the OT Prophets, nor for people with Jewish or other DNA.
RT does say that people who follow Judaism are no better off than those who follow Islam or Buddhism or atheism. That Jewish DNA is not an alternate path to salvation.
If that's "divisive," I suppose Christianity itself is divisive, in that Christianity says that all non-Christians won't make it to Heaven.
Should Christians preach that Jews and Muslims, atheists, Hindus, pagans and everyone else, will all be saved, in order not to be "divisive"?
Oh look
ANOTHER thread,,, in the bash dispensational Christians series.
Must be a day ending in a y.
Obsessive compulsive maliciousness.
Sad really.
Yep
I thought that dispensationalists believe the manifestations of the Holy Spirit (II Cor. 12) are not available today, a doctrine that is incorrect.
That's quite the generalization there. You can't make such a claim without some evidence or at least a rationalization for such an unloving view of your fellow Christians. And while your at it tell us what theology we should be believing.
I think you are confusing it with cessasionism.
“It provides a horrible basis for leaving a lasting legacy of faith and cultural renewal.” How? And what do you mean by cultural renewal? Stop with all the lofty wording and just speak plane English please.
CP, The article ultimately says that Dispensationalism in the U.S. is not actively doing harm, but that there are much larger issues afoot in America.
As support for this assertion, the author points out the fact that more than half of self-identified Christians, even more than half of so-called Evangelical Christians, are not aware that Jesus the Christ was not a created being. Which of course amounts to an horrific denial of Christ’s divinity.
Compare middle American architecture in the Bible Belt to….the great cities of European Christendom…Or art from prior centuries to goopy Christian media slop of today.
Some of this has due to with the stripped down, anti-art legacy of pragmatic Puritans who settled New England — but the point remains that there remains zero incentive or inspiration within modern day US Evangelicalism to say: BEAUTIFY our surroundings and cities for the greater glory of God and reflecting of His Kingdom *on earth.*
The Six Biggest Errors of Dispensationalism
https://prophecyquestions.com/the-six-biggest-errors-of-dispensationalism/In
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.