[one guy in new jersey]

The purloined host, being the body, blood, soul and Divinity of Jesus, Christ of the Father, is clearly more valuable than anything in the world.

If the sheikh in question, who irreverently headfaked toward consuming the host, did not subsequently consume it, where is it now?

The sheikh is portrayed as being a good friend to Catholics.
Has he agreed to return the host—the Holy Sacrament of the Altar?

[ebb tide]

If the sheikh in question, who irreverently headfaked toward consuming the host, did not subsequently consume it, where is it now?

From the posted article above:

The Sheik reportedly told the Vicar General that told the vicar general that he did not intend to “disrespect the Catholic Church,” revealing that he did in fact consume the host when he sat down in his pew. He added that the deceased cardinal had explained “that the Eucharist is the body of Jesus, considered a prophet for Islam.”