Catholic, was the prodigal son still a son even as he was immersed in the sin he eventually walked away from to return to the Father? Think, Catholic. There is no once a year every year remembrance of sin to be dealt with. Jesus dealt with ALL of it through His blood, establishing a new covenant forever.
Try a different gotcha.
Does unrepentant sin and walking away from the Father apply to entire church bodies as well?
Because let me tell you, there are two very big unrepentant sins committed by Catholicism right off the top of my head.
Snark about Catholicism’s sins aside, here’s the problem.
Catholicism doesn’t welcome the sinner back with joy. Catholicism says, “Sure you can come back, once you spend hundreds of years being tortured in Purgatory.”
Scripture says not. Paul says not. MHGinTN says not. Fala says not(!):
"But weborn-anew non-Catholics are not of themRomanly catechized Catholics who draw back unto perdition; but of themOSAS convinced that believe to the savingby the Savior Alone of the soul" (Heb 10:39 AV; superscripts interpretive explanations added).
>> It actually happens very often, usually a result of a tragedy. I have experienced this first hand in my family. <<
Your opinion is based on an unscriptural but catechised false assumption. What you apparently have not considered that the God-inspired Scripture is quite correct throughout from the beginning to its completion (at the time of Beloved John); nor of the fulfillment and abrogation of the Law Covenant by Jesus at the Cross, and finalized by the propitiation of man's sins by our High Priest in the offering of His Incorruptible Blood One-time Sacrifice before the Eyes of Our Heavenly Father, the same Blood Ever-fresh upon the Mercy Seat before Him, forever.
Thus, most probably your relative DID walk away from God's Gift, not trusting that whatever The Mighty Righteous God decides to allow to happen, results in good. ALWAYS.
And thus, your relative was not saved by infant baptism, nor by being catechized by another non-believer, nor saved by his/her own works, presumtively not by "Last Rites" applied by someone else either, but not personally and deliberaately casting ALL his/her cares upon Jesus (1 Pet. 5:7) accepting Salvation comprising Eternal Never-ending Absolute Life attainable by faith/change-of-mind Alone, the remedial trust wholly in Jesus Alone (2 Pet. 3:9,15), as confirmed by knowledge from Scripture Alone.
And thus to Hell for The Disbelieving, as the Jews mind-set was in John 10:22-41; announced by the lips of the God-Incarnate Messiah Alone, exercising Sword of the Spirit to separate the dead souls from their dead spirits.
Are you defying Heb. 10:39, which excludes true God-saved children from Heb. 6:6 and 10:26?