Are you sure? Imo, oo many differences. In 26 he Eli looks disbelieving and his hands are saying “Me?” In 4 there’s far more love in the face and his hands seem to be saying “Calm down.” Eli in 4 seems to be very approachable but Eli in 26 seems disconcerted.
Yep. Not identical, but only minor, unimportant differences. Note the similarities: carafe & jug upper-left; Eli’s footstool, beard, raised left hand; Samuel’s left hand on Eli’s knee, right hand pointing up.