Skip to comments.(Catholic) Bishops missing in action as Christian pastors defy California gov’s orders to hold worship services
Posted on 09/05/2020 6:07:53 PM PDT by ebb tide
September 4, 2020 (LifeSiteNews) As hundreds of Protestant pastors in California continue to offer worship services to the faithful, defying Governor Gavin Newsoms order, Catholic bishops continue to largely remain missing in action, what one Catholic professor referred to as a scandal.
Protestant pastors have strongly opposed the restrictions. One has filed a lawsuit challenging the order; another has said he will defy the order by opening his church, even if it results in his arrest.
God has not called us to be cowards, explained Pastor Che Anh of Harvest Rock Church in Pasadena, California to LifeSiteNews. The pastors see the need to mount a vigorous defense of the religious freedom they are guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution.
Meanwhile, Roman Catholic bishops in California have said nothing publicly that challenges Governor Newsoms Covid-19 restrictions. They have quietly accepted the states Covid-19 restrictions on worship, choosing cooperation over protest.
The bishops have advised parishes under their charge to hold outdoor services, which are permitted by the state government under certain conditions. Unfortunately, this advice is often not acted upon by individual parishes for a variety of reasons, including a lack of outdoor space. As a consequence, thousands of practicing Catholics throughout California are now denied participating in the Mass and partaking of the Blessed Sacrament.
Dr. Janet Smith, a retired professor who taught at Sacred Heart Major Seminary in Detroit, told LifeSiteNews that it is a scandal that Christians who do not believe in Christs real presence in the Eucharists are more zealous for their faith than Christians who do.
When asked why Protestant pastors in California had loudly protested the states Covid-19 restrictions while the leadership of the Catholic Church in the state had silently accepted them, Smith replied:
It could be that [the Protestant pastors] simply have more common sense and courage. If it is because they have more faith, how demoralizing is that? Wouldn't it be a great instance of Christian fraternity if the bishops linked arms with Protestant preachers (and those of other religions) to insist that religious liberty be honored?
Don't the bishops realize what a scandal it is that those who do not believe in the real presence of Jesus in the sacrament are more zealous to participate in worship than are the Roman Catholic bishops? I wouldn't be surprised if some Catholics begin going to Protestant services precisely to experience Christian community. Will they return? she added.
LifeSite contacted Bishop Edward Clark, Bishop Alejandro Aclan, and Bishop Robert Barron, each of whom runs a separate pastoral region in the Los Angeles Archdiocese, to ask them for comment.
In response, LifeSite received a statement from the Archdiocese, which read, in part: God calls us to protect all human life. While it has been difficult to suspend Masses indoors, we continue to celebrate the Eucharist and the Sacraments at outdoor Masses to limit the spread of Covid.
The statement did not address the challenges parishes face in holding outdoor services, nor did it question the constitutional validity of Governor Newsoms restrictions on churches.
Jesse Romero, a popular host on the Virgin Most Powerful Radio network, told LifeSiteNews that the bishops inaction may be connected to money.
"Remember what St. Paul tells us in 1 Timothy 6:10 -- For the love of money is the root of all kinds of evil. Some people, eager for money, have wandered from the faith, said Romero. If you want to know why the Roman Catholic bishops of California are so passive, those words explain why. Follow the money.
The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) receives roughly half of its $200 million operating budget from the U.S. government and through the approval of the Democratic Party. And who is the president of the USCCB right now? Archbishop Gomez of Los Angeles. And which political party runs California? The Democratic Party. The bishops aren't going to bite the hand that feeds them," he said.
LifeSite contacted the Archdiocese of San Francisco to see if Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone was willing to address these important issues. In response, Mike Brown, the Archdioceses Director of Communications, told LifeSiteNews the Archbishop was not available for an interview. He referred LifeSiteNews to the Archdioceses web site.
Cordiolene recently launched a petition calling on Mayor London Breed, Director of Public Health Dr. Grant Colfax, and San Francisco Health Officer Dr. Tomás Aragón, to ease restrictions that limit outdoor religious services to 12 people.
I am grateful that the Mayor and other government leaders in San Francisco acknowledge the importance of mental and spiritual health to the overall well-being of our people, in addition to physical and economic health. I am therefore calling on the Mayor and her public health officials to, at a minimum, remove the excessive limits on outdoor public worship, the petition reads.
Sins of omissions.
Yes, it is a sorry state of affairs that the leaders of these dioceses aren’t in the forefront. I know why. It’s the money from the govt. They certainly aren’t the types that brought Catholisim to the natives, like Father Marquett, et al.
If parishes don’t have enough room to hold an outdoor service at their usual place of worship, then it is up to them to find a site large enough to hold the service.
It seems like a lot of the Bishops are Frankies boys.
Jesus will spat them out of his mouth. They were neither cold nor hot.
The pastor of the church we had been attending not only seems to have no interest in opening, he went full black lives matter on his social media (pointed out by my kids). Probably wont be returning.
So that’s a huge red flag he’s not only not a Christian, but a Marxist who’s devoted to the overthrow of our Constitutional Government. These Stalinists, Satanists and Sodomites need to be driven out of every Christian institution.
You made a fatal error.
You applied logic. ;-)
My son called him out 3 times on social media. They deleted the first two, not sure about the third but he also called the guy out for not having the guts to defend his position.
No surprise. Try arguing with most leftists, they cannot defend their positions (and either resort to silencing critics or insults). I don’t know what sect he’s in, but if it still has even an ounce of Christianity left to it, I’d contact his higher-ups and report his blatant anti-Christian activities. People get canned over social media posts, and he should be no different.
Imagine if EVERY Catholic, Orthodox, Jewish, Evangelical, Protestant and, even, Muslim congregations joined together to defy the draconian and UNCONSTITUTIONAL restrictions on religious freedom to meet and worship free from state control! What are they going to do? Arrest and fine everyone? If people are permitted to protest, riot, burn and loot, why can't others join together to worship as they choose? This needs to happen now!
Good suggestion. I talked to my son and we are going to research a complaint. It is a huge church. We have been splitting time with our adult kids going to the churches they have chosen, but I told my son i didnt intend to go back to his church.
Please let us know if you’re able to do file that complaint and if there’s a response. Good Christians have got to take on and take down these frauds before they totally take over.
Good Christians have got to take on and take down these frauds before they totally take over.
The time to take down the political AND religious frauds will be November 4-10, and no letter of complaint will suffice to get that done!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.