[Jumping into your discussion with “Seek and Find”]
He asked you, in the first place, for specifics for your assertion that the question was “ludicrous”. Your answers have not been specific, but general and without meaning without some explanation. I find your responses evasive (not that I have any authority to make a judgement like that!), but I would appreciate some real specifics to round out your responses.
Oh, oh! I see, after posting, that my note went to “Seek and Find.” I meant to address “ifinnegin” with whom “Seek and Find” was carrying on this conversation.
So, “ifinnegin”, please take note!
I think you forgot to include him in your response :)