“And you base all of this on just what?...”
The teaching of all the popes from Peter through Pius XII.
(A vastly different position from that which Luther held.)
Some of your fellow Roman Catholics on these forums have told us we cannot make these kind of judgments you are making. we've been told only your priesthood can make these assessments.
This is where I see the disconnect in Roman Catholicism.
You allow yourself what you don't allow non-Roman Catholics...the ability to asses the veracity of a teaching.
I prefer like Luther to base on scripture