[Mrs. Don-o]

"If the answer is yes, the pope is wrong, and if it’s no, St. John Paul is wrong....Obviously these are not good faith questions!"

I disagree with you that these are not good faith questions. I had no problem answering them "No, yes, yes, yes, yes" in the order given.

If they demonstrate that the Pope was wrong in the way he formulated some of his statements in Amoris, he ought to gratefully accept this correction and make sure his doctrines do not flatly contradict those of his sainted predecessors.

That's part of the "One, Holy, Catholic, Apostolic" thing.

[Marchmain]

Ah! That would make his own the “snobbish ideology detached from doctrine”! Sadly, he stands on ceremony but without dignity.