I think you are confusing “valiant” with “effective,” “omniscient” and “presently convincing,” none of which I am claiming. The person made a far better effort and case than I am motivated to.
If you think you can do better, go ahead.
I'm surprised you're giving this any credence at all. Is a random blogger's opinions with no reference to Catholic teaching your idea of a "real reference"? Or is it noteworthy because you tend to agree with it?
This isn't about whether *I* can do better. It's about seeking out explanations anchored in the teaching of the Catholic Church.