[Campion]

You're also having to ignore a number of other texts that indicate Mary and Joseph did have other children on their own

Nobody in Scripture is identified as a biological child of Mary except Jesus.

[ealgeone]

>>You're also having to ignore a number of other texts that indicate Mary and Joseph did have other children on their own.

Nobody in Scripture is identified as a biological child of Mary except Jesus.

However Scripture does tell us Jesus had brothers and sisters.

Joseph kept Mary a virgin until He was born then they were free to consummate the marriage like any regular married couple....and that they did. Unless you're willing to again suspend the clear, normal meaning of the texts.

[ravenwolf]

Nobody in Scripture is identified as a biological child of Mary except Jesus.

---

That is right.

Both James and Joses is recognized as the sons of another Mary who is the wife of Clopas.