Has it ever occurred to you that just maybe we might agree with the opinions posted and would like to say so???
On the other hand, there have been Catholic Caucus threads posted that did NOT obey the Caucus rules and were sneakily trying to slip past the Moderator. I'd guess that this has happened FAR more frequently here. I know I've exposed a few myself and have successfully challenged their categorization. Maybe THAT is what irks some so much?
I got unceremoniously uninvited from a caucus thread one time years back for that exact thing.
It was about a priest who lost his job for standing his ground about something he believed and I had a lot of respect and admiration for that kind of character.
My posts were positive and I was booted and told by the Catholics that it wasn't because of the content of my posts, but it was because of who I was.
So they don't even allow others the opportunity to agree with them and yet complain that all we do is criticize.
You can't win with some folks.
From my experience, "No". And this thread has confirmed it.
THIS is exactly what I've seen happen from some of our Roman Catholic posters.
And then, some, when the caucus thread is removed, complain to the RM about the label being removed!
Bottom line is this....if you're posting using the caucus label....it's YOUR responsibility to be sure the article meets the guidelines.