[who_would_fardels_bear]

What about John and Jane where they both present themselves as devout Catholics, but John fails to mention he's divorced and did not have his previous marriage annulled?

How will the Catholic baker know not to bake them a cake?

[ebb tide]

Do you think Catholic bakers just bake cakes for Catholics?

If so, I doubt your sanity.

[ebb tide]

If your daughter comes home from college with her live-in boy friend, will you let them sleep in the same room?

[ebb tide]

What about John and Jane where they both present themselves as devout Catholics,...

What about the same John and Jane presenting themselves for Holy Communion in a neighboring parish? Do you expect to the priest to demand marriage certificates from each communicant beforehand?