[Fedora]

[Original:]“God is our Father (Matthew 6:9; cf. John 1:12-13); Jesus is the Son of God; Mary is Jesus’ mother; therefore, Mary is our Mother.”

[Reply:]This doesn’t pass any logic test at all.

Feel free to identify which logical fallacies you identified. I can rewrite it as a syllogism or in symbolic logic if you prefer.

[aMorePerfectUnion]

Feel free to identify which logical fallacies you identified. I can rewrite it as a syllogism or in symbolic logic if you prefer.

Here is where you had the breakdown: Mary is Jesus’ mother; therefore, Mary is our Mother.”

It does not follow that since Mary is Jesus mother, that she is the mother of every Christian.

[metmom]

Easy.

Mary is not God’s wife. She is not deity.