Skip to comments.
Liberal Christianity – the bastard daughter of the Enlightenment
Pastoral Meanderings ^
| 01-05-2016
| Pastor Peters
Posted on 01/05/2016 9:51:34 AM PST by NRx
Liberal Christianity - the bastard daughter of the Enlightenment... now there is a line you are not soon to forget. I wish I could say I had written it
but I did not. And another one, well, several lines:
Unlike either the Renaissance or the Reformation, the Enlightenment had begun not as an attempt to rescue some hallowed past, but as an assault on the past in the name of the future...It was a period which sought to overturn every intellectual assumption, every dogma, every 'prejudice' (a favourite term) that had previously exercised any hold over the minds of men. Anthony Pagden.
There is the problem. Too often shallow history sees the Enlightenment is seen as one side of the coin of which the Reformation is the other -- a vast movement of freedom casting off the constraints of authoritarianism, Biblicism, and dogmatism in favor of a Star Trek approach to the understanding of God and man -- to boldly go where no man has gone before. What foolishness!
The Reformation began as a quest FOR authority -- not some contrived authority posited in men or councils who may agree for a moment only to change their minds later but an eternal authority that has the yesterday, today, and forever stamp upon it. Luther was a man on a quest not from the past but into the past, to the church before institutions had assumed what belonged to the voice of the Apostles and their written words that carried the authority of the Son of God. It was never a sola scriptura in the sense of the Bible alone, naked, ripped from the community of faith and the succession of believers whose creeds and confessions flowed from the living Word. It was never a sola under the domain of reason trying to tie up God's loose ends and systematize and organize a God who often appears wild (gadfry, Lutherans have never really produced much in the way of systematic theology to tame the untamed God or His Word). We live within the comfort of paradox that seems to conflict but lives at the same time awaiting the fullness of the Spirit and the disclosure which will render the questions mute.
Liberal Christianity is surely the bastard daughter of the Enlightenment. It is the repudiation of authority and the invention of truth on a relative scale, ever evolving and never the same. It is centered not in God nor in His Word but in man, the god who lives at the center of all things and rules his universe (if only from the vantage point of his own mind). Liberal Christianity eschews authority and truth just as much as the Enlightenment takes on as its guiding principle the refutation of the past. Liberalism always appears egalitarian but is in reality the most snobbish and elite of ideas. Freedom yes but not for all -- everyone else must live within the politically corrected vocabulary and ideas that have the approval of the cultural elite for the idea that we are all free and equal is, of course, an illusion. Some are always freer and more equal than others.
Lutherans are so often misunderstood even as they so often misunderstand themselves. The golden thread through our Confessions is not any of the buzz words of the Enlightenment but rather the clear and manifest insistence that we have not deviated from Scripture, from catholic doctrine, or from catholic practice and, in this regard, we are the fruit of the one authority that is genuine and that has the power to hold up our lives -- the efficacious means of grace in the Word and Sacraments who are the God whom we confess at work to deliver what He has promised to all who will receive His gifts.
TOPICS: History; Mainline Protestant; Theology
KEYWORDS: religiousleft
1
posted on
01/05/2016 9:51:34 AM PST
by
NRx
To: NRx
Liberal Christianity eschews authority I suppose it appeals to those who saw Jesus as a rebel against both Roman authority and the increasingly secular Jewish leadership.
2
posted on
01/05/2016 9:53:50 AM PST
by
A_perfect_lady
(Welfare: It's a Safety Net, Not a Hammock.)
To: NRx
And then we got Pope Francis
3
posted on
01/05/2016 10:12:42 AM PST
by
stocksthatgoup
(Trump and Cruz are not attacking each other. Why don't their follows take note)
To: NRx
That damned enlightenment. Why can’t people just accept the theocracy of their betters? You know, better, like the Borgias, like Martin Luther, like the murderous Calvin? /
The enlightenment is very good in every way, most religious structures before it, evil and unChristlike.
4
posted on
01/05/2016 11:03:17 AM PST
by
DesertRhino
("I want those feeble minded asses overthrown,,,")
To: NRx
Liberal Christianity is surely the bastard daughter of the Enlightenment.I respectfully disagree. It is the bastard daughter of Romanticism.
A reasonably good portion of the Enlightenment, especially among thinkers like Locke and Kant (Locke from the view of rights, Kant from the view of duty), believed that the combination of evidence and reason led to truth, with the main difference between L/K and Luther or Calvin being that the latter accepted Scripture as sufficient evidence. For example, Kant's Categorical Imperative, in its various formulations, was supposed to lead to the same result as the Golden Rule, with the difference being that he could reasonably prove the CI, while accepting the GR requires the acceptance of Scripture as an evidentiary tool. Such Enlightenment thinking does not ipso facto lead to small-o orthodoxy, but it doesn't necessarily lead away from it either.
Contrast that with the basic tenets of Romanticism, and its philosophical cousin, the Hegelian dialectic. Romanticism is the philosophy that turns classic thinking on its head: feelings are more important than facts, civilization corrupts human purity, organized Christianity is harmful to progress, nature is worthy of adoration--along with the replacement of the classical elements of beauty (balance, harmony, proportion) with a fascination with the grotesque, the bizarre, the exotic-for-the-sake-of-exotic.
To change the metaphor slightly, liberal, heterodox-to-heretical Christianity is the Bride of Romanticism rather than the Bride of Christ.
It changes doctrines because of feelings: it feels bad because homosexuals can't marry their lovers so it changes the doctrine of marriage, it feels bad because women have to carry unwanted pregnancies so it changes the doctrine of abortion, it feels bad about people going to hell so it changes the doctrine of hell.
It assumes anything that comes from Western civilization corrupts because it is (supposedly) racist, sexist, filled with "white privilege," and that we have much to learn from third-world religions because they are closer to nature and not corrupted by European imperialism. [This is why it is ambivalent towards Islam, because Islam is an organized religion, but it is perceived as not corrupted by European imperialism, so it has to be somehow better than Christianity, though liberals are not sure just how.]
Finally, it is willing to shrink the God of the Bible and magnify the Goddess of Nature, placing environmentalism above husbandry--which itself is a sexist term, of course.
The Enlightenment at its worst led to Deism or scientism, but never to chaotic primitivism; at its best, it provided Christianity the means of proving itself with evidence and reason alongside faith and spiritual understanding. An Enlightenment thinker can easily become a Christian--in the 20th century we saw this in a number of instances, from C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien to Mortimer Adler and Marvin Olasky--because the trek is simply a series of steps in the same direction. For someone who is a liberal Christian, however, a complete conversion of thinking is required, a replacement of Romanticist platitudes with orthodox thinking and orthopraxic living. That is why I disagree with the premise of this article.
5
posted on
01/05/2016 11:08:35 AM PST
by
chajin
("There is no other name under heaven given among people by which we must be saved." Acts 4:12)
To: chajin
Pretty good analysis there.
6
posted on
01/05/2016 11:16:15 AM PST
by
DesertRhino
("I want those feeble minded asses overthrown,,,")
To: DesertRhino
I thought so, too. It’s those who wish to reyoke humanity to the plow of ecclesiastical servitude that decry enlightenment most loudly.
7
posted on
01/05/2016 11:52:25 AM PST
by
sparklite2
( "The white man is the Jew of Liberal Fascism." -Jonah Goldberg)
To: chajin; DesertRhino
Yes, this is a good analysis, but somewhat incomplete. The line of demarcation between Enlightenment and Romantic thinkers is not as rigid as implied. The rationalism and empiricism of the Scientific Revolution and Enlightenment are presupposed by many Romantic writers, where one of their main complaints was that the pendulum had swung too far away from intuition as a means of acquiring knowledge. Moreover, Liberal Christianity generally presupposes the validity of the higher critical approach to the Bible as these studies unfolded throughout the 19th century and thereafter based on principles of rationalism and empiricism, and in parallel with the Romantic ideas of the time. Liberal Christianity is a hybrid, an amalgam of ideas from rationalism and empiricism on the one hand, and Romanticism and spiritualism on the other. It is often logically inconsistent and emotionally ambivalent. Apparent exceptions to the foregoing can always be found in certain specific statements by individual writers, but this can also lead to missing the forest for the trees.
Yet another contribution to the mishmash of ideas that is Liberal Christianity comes from psychoanalysis in the concept of reaction formation. Due (in part) to the brutality, horrors and excesses of the wars of religion during early modern times—culminating in the Thirty Years War and also including the violent repudiation of the divine right of kings during the French Revolution—many Westerners have turned their underlying animalistic impulses into their opposite in a sort of exaggerated pacifistic, brotherhood-of-man mentality that often amounts to suicidal altruism. Rather than again risk giving free reign to the savage brute within, adherents of this position are self-sacrificing (and politically correct) to such an extreme degree as to place their own interests below those of intruders from hostile, alien cultures who are only too happy to exploit this weakness.
I especially like the idea that Liberals are constantly changing definitions and lowering standards in order to be more inclusive toward those who were previously viewed as acting contrary to the interests of society. In addition to the examples given, I would add one of my favorites, which is the redefinition of crime in a way that decriminalizes the conduct of those who are unable or unwilling to conform to social expectations. Another example is the redefinition of music, as in the hip-hop or rap culture, so as to include grunts, shouts, yelps, primitive rhythms, etc.
8
posted on
01/05/2016 1:24:09 PM PST
by
FJB
To: FJB; DesertRhino
Thank you; I truly appreciate the thought you put into your response. You have taken the idea and drilled deeper. Let me repay you, if I can, by adding a little more...
The rationalism and empiricism of the Scientific Revolution and Enlightenment are presupposed by many Romantic writers
That's true, particularly among the earlier Romantics, the Shelleys/Wollstonecrafts, Byron, Blake, etc. If it hadn't been for Voltaire on the one hand and Hegel on the other, theirs would have been more critiques of the Enlightenment, rather than a rebellion against what they perceived as its arrogance--and when you have Kant saying he can explain the Golden Rule better than Jesus, you have arrogance. The excesses of the Romantics don't seem to truly show themselves until the 1830s, which may have something to do with the political upheavals that occur after Napoleon--in Europe in general and France in particular--and/or the Transcendentalists, and/or the winding down of the Second Great Awakening, and/or the reappearance of Asian thought via the British from India and China.
Liberal Christianity generally presupposes the validity of the higher critical approach to the Bible as these studies unfolded throughout the 19th century and thereafter based on principles of rationalism and empiricism
This is also true, but it points to liberal Christianity's ideological nature. When science seemed to prove, to use one example, that the plagues and the Exodus could not have occurred, the higher critics were gleeful, because it seemed to undercut the Bible as an authority in doctrinal matters. But when more recent evidence points to the likelihood of the plagues and the Exodus, that evidence is discarded as so much garbage, because it undercuts those who would undercut the Bible--which, of course, is the same way liberal Christianity is more concerned about manmade global warming, in spite of all the evidence against it, because they are as zealous for Nature as the orthodox Christian is zealous for God.
Yet another contribution to the mishmash of ideas that is Liberal Christianity comes from psychoanalysis in the concept of reaction formation.
This comes much later, beginning with Freud of course, and I won't argue with the direction you took it, that we have come to emphasize pacifism to the detriment of the Christian-as-warrior. But I would add another effect: it is Freud who provides the rationalization for thinking of humans, not as being made in the image of God, but as being primarily sexual beings, who work out their sexual salvation, to mangle the Christian metaphor. This shows itself in numerous ways today, because there are two principles at work: the principle that we are primarily sexual, and the principle that we are most pure when we refuse all civilizing restrictions. Put those together, and you end up with the attitude towards sex, and relationships defined by sex (homosexual, pedophilic, incestuous, polygamous, etc.), that you see in the liberal world in general and among liberal Christian churches in particular.
And one more thing, as the musicologist rises...
the redefinition of music, as in the hip-hop or rap culture, so as to include grunts, shouts, yelps, primitive rhythms, etc.
Quite true, and this is the alignment of two vectors: the one that civilization corrupts but primitive is pure, and the one that beauty is found not in the harmonious but in the grotesque.
But there is a deeper problem here. Music is the means by which God opens the door for Him to commune with our spiritual selves, the selves that go beyond the psychikos anthropos to the pneumaton ton theon (I Corinthians 2:14), from human reason to the Spirit of God. We see this from the way music affects brain chemistry, in much the way that drugs affect brain chemistry. But modern popular music is designed, purposefully or not, to manipulate this aspect, to overwhelm the brain and block the door, so that music becomes an addictive commodity. The Romantic composers understood this and tried to create the experience, but did not have the technology to make it so. Berlioz tried to double the orchestra as did Mahler after him, and Liszt stretched the piano to its limits, but it wasn't enough--it took electrical amplification and electronic effects, which today we have in abundance. But ask most people today about music, and they will either talk about the lyrics or about the experience (e.g., what happened at the concert), because there is little to nothing that can be said about the popular music of today, other than it is a drug to be mixed with other, chemical drugs.
In music, liberalism dissolves into nihilism...and that is coming in the other aspects as well. And the reaction to nihilism is always tyranny, whether the tyranny of the individual (like Napoleon after the French Revolution, or Hitler after Weimar), of the tyranny of the ideology, like Bolshevism after WWI, or, may it please God not to happen, like Islam in the West today.
9
posted on
01/05/2016 3:27:32 PM PST
by
chajin
("There is no other name under heaven given among people by which we must be saved." Acts 4:12)
To: chajin
A thoughtful and informative rejoinder. You are indeed a gentleman and a scholar (and apparently also a musicologist). Thanks for the discussion.
Referring back to the original article, there are many good treatments of the Enlightenment and the Romantic Movement. Unfortunately, discussions of the latter are often segregated according to discrete subject areas, such as literature, philosophy, art, music, etc. For those who are interested, an excellent, wide-ranging treatment is, The Romantic Conception of Life: Science and Philosophy in the Age of Goethe, by Robert J. Richards (who is one of our most gifted practitioners of intellectual history). Goethe was a fascinating character, a true Renaissance man who reflected and embodied the ethos of both the Enlightment and Romanticism.
10
posted on
01/05/2016 4:33:18 PM PST
by
FJB
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson