So we evidently have to answer the question, Is Cardinal Dolan Catholic? differently from the question Is the Pope Catholic?
Is Cardinal Dolan Catholic?
I would call him a fake Catholic, cafeteria Catholic, but never just a Catholic and absolutely not a faithful Catholic.
He gives Holy Communion it pro-abortion politicians and never opens his mouth about the evils of homosexuality. He caters to them. It’s a truly sordid state of affairs.
http://www.churchmilitant.tv/platform/?vidID=vort-2015-03-18