LOL! It’s my fault for how I wrote the post. The whole thing is an exercise in demonstrating exactly what you said. Read it again with that in mind and it should become clear I’m actually arguing against the genetic fallacy Catholics sometimes use to define and categorize non-Catholics. I could have been more clear. Sorry for any confusion.
Perhaps I made a mistake in misunderstanding your thrust by me reading it too quickly. If I made a mistake please excuse me, I didn't intend to offend --