[DuncanWaring]

I never said she didn’t need a Savior.

But, now that you bring it up, perhaps having been judged worthy to be the mother of Jesus, and sinless, she in fact did not need a Savior.

And, why do you say her father, Saint Joachim, was not earthly?

[ealgeone]

I never said she didn’t need a Savior.

If you are sinless, why do you need a Savior??

But, now that you bring it up, perhaps having been judged worthy to be the mother of Jesus, and sinless, she in fact did not need a Savior.

She was not sinless. That would be a contradiction of Romans 3:23. The RCC claims their "sacred tradition" doesn't contradict Scripture. Someone is in error. Either the Bible or the RCC. I'm saying the RCC is in error.

And, why do you say her father, Saint Joachim, was not earthly?

My error...I was thinking of Christ.

But now that you bring this up....not sure why you are calling Joachim Saint....afterall, we are all saints if we are followers of Christ. This is another made-up title to separate people by the RCC. The Bible clearly teaches all who follow Christ are saints.