I think you make a reasonable argument. Since it is a subjective topic, there will be different opinions, which could all be equally valid.
Now, how did the thread go so far afield?
“Now, how did the thread go so far afield?”
Unfortunately, many of the religion threads are so reflexively Anti-Catholic or Anti-Protestant that participants assume everything is an attack. I’ve met both Catholic priests and Baptist preachers who could give good marriage counseling, and I’ve met some of both who I wouldn’t ask for directions to cross a street.