[Jeff Chandler]

So Catholic charismatics are heretics?

Not necessarily. Most of them are probably just silly and naive.

[CTrent1564]

good answer, it is way of expressing the faith that I don’t care for. They are not heretics otherwise the movement would have been condemned long ago. It is Legitimately sanctioned movement within the Church in communion with the Bishops, but is it not a movement that I would ever affiliate with in terms of prayer meetings like this one.

There are many Gifts of the Holy Spirit, I just prefer to let other people experience and associate with said gifts!!!

Not my cup of tea, but they are Catholic in that they don’t reject Catholic Doctrine, there way of expressing said doctrine does not really interest me at all.

[daniel1212]

Not necessarily. Most of them are probably just silly and naive.

So if not all are heretics, and most of them are probably just silly and naive, are any right in claiming they have the gifts such as tongues?

[Biggirl]

In truth, many of those folks are devout Catholics who have a love for the Lord in both the Bible and sacraments.