So how would a faithful Catholic respond to the calumnies above at 821?
A poster expresses an odius opinion, clearly his opinion. Since we cannot make this about him or his opinion or even his expressed beliefs, no matter how weird or whacko they may be, what is acceptable?
The rest was making it personal though you could have said "Nothing you said debunks that."
Your posts are like lightning rods - you must be doing something right!! Thanks for not backing down!