Incest/rape is a wrong reason and I’d rebuke them for doing this.
However triage of life in an either/or situation is an unavoidable situation. In pretending to be so simon-pure, Catholics have used delicate language in talking about such matters as tubal pregnancies.
If it were for the sake of God that they were wanting to save these lives, they’d have a leg to stand on and they’d also have something they could urge the rest of “erring” Christendom about. However it appears that they have virtually idolized “life” — made it a brag point — and thus are doing the “right thing for the wrong reasons.” If I am looking for a church (in the modern sense of worship community) to go to, I don’t want to hear that you are a “life” church! I want to hear that you are a “God” church! Because my “life” as you are cheering it on ends when I die. But the “life” as God affirms lasts forever. Again, once saved always saved... Baptists are MORE pro-life there. In the context that means the most to God.
Amen! Well said.