In order for his idea to work, either the gravity on Earth is so high that the Earth crushes itself into superdense degenerate matter or the repulsive force for bodies beyond the Earth prevents those very same bodies from forming in the first place.
Aww gosh shucks I guess your just too smart for me - is that supposed to be my response to you?
Listen up sonny boy - there is no science nor scientist on Earth knowing everything. Furthermore there are no scientific instruments that can measure everything either - some conditions are just too extreme to verify the conjectures that most science is built upon. Lastly science is never science when it is discussing past history no matter whether thousands nor billions of years. There are no scientific experiments that can simulate the passage of time nor declare what the prior nor starting conditions were [this applies to your prior posts too].
So please heckle all you want it just shows your true motives.