They get plenty of that without the involvement of catholic schools, believe me.
A protestant friend of mine uses your argument all the time -- equally fallacious there. In fact, he used it to say his kids might as well go to a public school rather than a faith-oriented school. That's not a line of reasoning I'm going to engage in. Why not just go to a known Satanic school to prepare for the very worst?
You are correct. I have a friend who teaches 8th grade, and she says the only thing most of these kids can memorize are lines from Bachelor Part 2 or the latest vulgar rap song.
These kids are inundated with cultural trash on a daily basis. A shame that schools would waste a golden opportunity to expose kids to that which is true and good.
Whole Cloth arguments you have there...
Why not require the reading, to allow PRODUCTIVE discussions, and leadership from the School on the depravity-obsessed foolishness?
Oh...that's right, hear no evil, see no evil, speak no evil.....that's the ticket (pretend it doesn't exist).