The notion that two opposing views are both right is positively Orwellian. The notion that they are both right unless one of them happens to be Catholic is positively Satanic.
Actually, it's positively Catholic.
Only when Catholics teach two opposing views on something, they call it a *mystery* and say that it needs to be accepted by *faith*, because they know that nobody in their right minds can rationalize tow diametrically opposed teachings.