“I will congratulate you on your admission of your misunderstanding of the Magisterial office. Individual doctrinal opinions do not a Church make.”
And I am sure you will find for me where those Popes and Bishops were condemned by the Magisterium they were a part of. After all, they were teaching contrary to the long-held tradition of the church.
“This is the first admission of misunderstanding that I have seen you make since you have rejoined FR under another name. I must pat you on the shoulder and call you George.”
Unfortunately, this isn’t the first time I’ve seen you resort to pathetically weak arguments followed up with an Ad-hom.
Discuss the issues all you want, but do not make it personal.
Sure. The Catechism contains the Catholic beliefs. The fact that certain individual bishops' beliefs are not in there are admonishment enough.
But if you want examples, let us look to Marcion, to Arius, to Tertullian, to Lucifer Calaritanus, to Macedonius I, to Eutechys, to Mani, to Constantine the Armenian, to Priscillian, to Valentinus, to Audius, to Donatus Magnus, to Montanus, to Pelagius, to Henry of Lausanne, to Otto Jansen, to Marie Paule Giguère, to Leonard Feeney, and a whole raft of other bishops and theologians. Expressly and in detail, condemned as heretical by the Church.
Unfortunately, this isn’t the first time I’ve seen you resort to pathetically weak arguments followed up with an Ad-hom.
Nice to see your rerun tag.