[ZX12R]

But clearly the evidence presented above should rule out any sort of automatic dismissal of the prophecies.

It's still an automatic dismissal from me. And that goes for Nostradamus and Edgar Cayce too.

[Brian Kopp DPM]

I ignore anything that doesn't have Church approval or a clear proof of its origin from a Venerable, Blessed or Canonized Saint. There's more than enough Catholic prophecy from credible sources than one need not worry about the supposed St. Malachi prophecies. Nonetheless, I found this blog post interesting.