Who is the "us" you are referring to and are your efforts exclusively politically motivated or do you care about the Salvation of said Catholics?
Nearly as many Catholics did not vote at all as voted for both parties. By definition, you have no exit polling data on the reasons they did not vote. It is entirely possible that they did not vote because they had moral objections to both parties. Although it has not prevented me from voting I too have moral problems with both parties.
Peace be with you.
“The Catholic vote is large and important, unfortunately it is pro-democrat and pro-abortion, stop defending it, and help us crack it, fix it, change it from it’s historical place in the democrat column.”
“Us” is pro-lifers and conservatives, that should not need to be explained to a freeper.