All in the eyes of the beholder I would confidently say.
God sees us thru the life of His son...not Mary...it is His blood shed for us,.. not Mary's.....We do not need to worsip Mary via "Mariology"....when we have "Christ-ianity" as our faith and the centrality of Christ as our foundation. 'He is the Rock' to stand on...all else is sinking sand.
If the beholder is competently taught Christian Orthodoxy, s/he will see that the statement: "as if God needed a mother" reveals mushy nonsensical understanding of the Most Holy Trinity.
The other statements merely compound the nonsense.