All you have to do is to ask yourself; "if the Church Fathers came back today which Church would they attend". I have no doubts that they would feel completely at home in the Catholic Church and would completely reject much of Protestantism.
I don’t think any church would be according to what they saw as the church. The problems of Homosexual Priests would certainly be a red light to them in what is happening in all churches leaderships now....infidelity to one another and their mates also would be an affront...
If the founding Fathers came back they would go about clearing out the trash and all which is an affront to Christ...and his church body...and none would be exempt...and there certainly isn’t one they’d feel at home in...impossible.
Considering that they would also have the Eastern Orthodox, the Oriental Orthodox (Syrians, Copts, Armenians, Ethiopians, and Malankaras), and the non-Ephesians (Assyrians and Mellusians) to choose from, that is a ridiculous statement.
By the way, the church fathers were not only creationist--they were geocentrist as well.