[bkaycee]

Are you free from sin, due to Christ’s sacrifice? If you are, she is.

Christians are free from the penalty of sin, but still sin.

Are you saying Mary was sinless, but still sinned?

[Judith Anne]

What do you care? Are you putting me under your scriptural microscope for fun? I’m not having fun, and I quit. You said Mary’s role was finished when she gave birth to Christ. I asked for scriptural proof. You furnished none, and changed the question.

Are you free from sin? Or not? Are you “in Christ” as Paul says, or not? What does that mean to you? Are you washed whiter than snow? And what do you care what I say about Mary? You have mede it clear you believe none of it, so, forget it. Go find some other Catholic to play your proddy games.

[metmom]

Christians are free from the penalty of sin, but still sin.

That cannot be repeated enough. That is the point the Catholics seem to miss wholesale.