Corapi's 10 Percent Solution [the sacramental life was only 10 percent of his priesthood]

Patheos ^ | June 21, 2011 | Greg Kendra

[Alex Murphy]

Of all the bizarre comments contained in John Corapi's rambling speech on Monday, there was one that struck me as especially strange, and particularly sad.

Near the beginning, when he makes clear that he's not actually leaving the priesthood, but only suspending his public work as a priest (and dropping the title "Father"), he shrugs off the impact this will have on his life. Nothing much will change, he says, explaining that he really had little to do with the sacraments, anyway—saying mass, hearing confession, anointing the sick.

"I didn't do very much of that quite honestly in the twenty years that I did minister," he says, adding, "90 percent of what I did in the past did not require ordination. Speaking through social communication—radio, TV, so forth—that's not ministry, strictly speaking. My particular mission was speaking, writing, and teaching—not so much in the sacraments, but outside of them, in conjunction with them. So what I'm going to be doing in the future is pretty much the same thing."

Well. I have to appreciate his candor. But off the top of my head, I can't think of any priest I know who has so effectively and completely marginalized—even minimized—the most transcendent aspect of his priesthood: celebrating the sacraments. Any one who has been given the great gift of Holy Orders knows that ordination is not strictly about what we do, but about what we are, and what we become. And yet, a priest becomes, by sacred ordination, alter Christus, another Christ. Fundamental to that is grace—the grace to reconcile the penitent, anoint the sick, baptize new Catholics and, most humbling and overwhelming of all, transform bread and wine into the body and blood of Christ in the sacrifice of the mass.

To John Corapi, it seems, that really didn't matter so much. It didn't seem to matter much to his superiors, either, who allowed him to live apart—a Black Sheepdog or a Lone Wolf.

At a time when parishes are starving for priests, and some men are spending hours every Sunday on the road, shuttling from parish to parish to celebrate mass and hear confessions, John Corapi, like Bartleby the Scrivener, shrugged and said, "I prefer not to."

And that, evidently, was fine. He had other things to do. He traveled, he spoke, he recorded, he wrote books. He strode across stadium stages to thunderous applause and cried out for repentance and faithfulness, and told again and again of his astonishing journey from rags to riches to rags to redemption. He confronted medical crises, and fought legal battles, and emerged even stronger. And that was fine, too. He had something to say, and thousands, if not millions, who wanted to hear it. He was an ardent and impassioned defender of the faith.

But I can't escape the feeling that something was missing, and that Corapi himself was missing something.

Talk to any priest you know. Ask him: "What's the best part about being a priest? What do you love about it?"

I did that the other day, after the Corapi news broke. I talked to a handful of priests. Again and again, I got the same answers: "Saying mass." "Hearing confession." "Offering the sacraments."

Hearing that, and thinking of John Corapi, I thought of other priests, in other circumstances.

I thought of Fr. Henri Perrin, who wrote so movingly of secretly celebrating mass on Palm Sunday in 1944 in a German concentration camp:

When I held the sacrifice between my fingers, I was holding up to God in complete faith the lives of all the men sleeping round me."

I thought of the priests of Dachau, who were forbidden to say mass, but did so anyway, risking their lives. According to one account:

During the time that the Polish priests were not allowed to say Mass, they asked the priest from Block 26, who was in charge of the chapel, to give them hosts and wine so they could celebrate Mass in secret. The Polish priests who worked on the plantation (farm) at Dachau would kneel on the ground and pretend to be weeding. They had a small portable altar which one of the priests would press into the ground. The priests would kneel down and receive Communion from their own hands.

And I thought of the Vietnamese Cardinal Nguyen van Thaun, who spent decades in prison, facing persecution and risking death by secretly saying mass for himself and his fellow prisoners. In 2008, his sister described his life behind bars:

During an interview with the media after his release, he was asked what his secret strength had been that kept him alive and sane. His answer was always, "The Eucharist." He explained how when he was arrested, he had to leave immediately, empty-handed. The following day he was allowed to write to his faithful to ask for some personal effects. He wrote: "Please send me a little wine as medicine for my stomach pain." They understood right away. A few days later, the guards handed him a small container addressed to him, and labeled "Medicine for stomach aliments." He also received another small container containing small pieces of Holy Host.

With three drops of wine and a drop of water in the palm of his hand, he would celebrate Mass. "Each time I celebrated Mass, I had the opportunity to extend my hands and nail myself to the cross with Jesus, to drink with Him the bitter chalice" (Testimony of Hope). And those were the most beautiful Masses of his life.

In Testimony of Hope he continued: In the re-education camp, we were divided into groups of 50 prisoners. We slept on a common bed, and everyone had the right to 50 cm of space. We managed to make sure there were Catholics around me. At 9:30 pm, we had to turn off the light. It was then that I would bend over the bed to celebrate Mass by heart, and I distributed communion by passing my hand under the mosquito net. We even made little bags with the aluminum foil from cigarette packs to preserve the Holy Host and take it to others. The Eucharistic Jesus was always present in my shirt pocket.

I have to wonder if John Corapi knew that sort of consolation. Did he even care? For these and other priests, the Eucharist was all. For John Corapi, it was, at best, 10 percent of his priesthood.

Sorry. That's just not enough. And it may be one reason, among many, why he now finds himself in his present state.

This Sunday, the church will celebrate the great feast of Corpus Christi, honoring the Body and Blood of Jesus Christ. (In an interesting irony, Corpus Christi is also the name of the diocese where Corapi's order is headquartered; it is the bishop of Corpus Christi whom Corapi attacks in his taped statements.)

This is a time to cherish what we have been given in the Eucharist, and to look at Jesus Christ, present to us in the Flesh—more present to us than any man, or even many people we know and love on earth. It might be a useful time to remember, as well, the sacrifices that have been made to make this holy sacrament possible—the blood that's been shed, the tears that have been wept, the risks that have been taken by great priests like Nguyen van Thaun and Henri Perrin.

It might be a time to pray, as well, for John Corapi.

[Campion]

It’s not an absolute, iron-clad requirement for a Latin Rite priest to say Mass daily, but it’s strongly encouraged — a duty which should not be waived for a non-serious reason.

[BlatherNaut]

“Fr. Corapi has always seen the priesthood as a vehicle to become a multi-millionaire”

You have proof of this? How do you know how Fr. Corapi views the priesthood? Did he tell you this personally? “Let not mercy and truth leave thee”....(Proverbs 3:3).

“he’s a maverick with a private (for profit) company. This is unheard of.”

Not in his order. As his SOLT superior has explained, when Fr. Corapi entered the order, the founder expected members to support themselves. These arrangements were sanctioned by his superior.

“The cause here is Corapi’s personal wealth and ego gratification”.

Are you privy to his financial statements? If not, you have no idea what he does with the money. And why assume he is seeking ego gratification? Are you privy to his psychological disposition?

“As my earlier posts have explained, to some scorn, he never should have been ordained.”

I didn’t see any scorn regarding your earlier comment - only honest disagreement. And since the Church grants dispensations regarding priestly eligibility, there are no absolutes regarding ordination.

[wmfights]

Thank you for the info.

[michigancatholic]

What a lot of cradle catholics don’t get is this: A lot of priests are not in parish ministry. Let me repeat: A lot of priests are not in parish ministry. Let that sink in.

Many, many priests teach, work in offices, are even groundskeepers & bookkeepers for church properties.

Your Bing Crosby mental image is a figment of your imagination.

Get a grip and some perspective, people.

A note to about 3/4 of the Catholics I know: Please get past being in the 6th grade when it comes to your religion. Grow up. It won’t kill you. It may help you and it will certainly help the church.

[michigancatholic]

BTW, Dcn Kendra knows that many priests are not engaged in parish ministry. He also knows that many catholics aren’t very well informed on this, and that this can be used for effect.

Dcn Kendra blogs for Patheos, which is a very progressive thing. Have a look, but the more innocent of you might want to make sure you’re sitting down first: http://www.patheos.com/