I am guessing you are sending the other poster a similar note about accusing me of being a militant anti-Christian, and of attacking the Christian culture of America--or are those things not "making it personal" because I'm an atheist, so anything goes?
This is based on the principle that two wrongs do not make a right.
Much like liberals can be trolls on the News/Activism Forum, atheists can be trolls on the Religion Forum.
Atheists are welcome to participate in theological debate provided their posts have a theological, historical or philosophical context. When the atheist has nothing to bring but ad hominems, I instruct him to leave.