[the_conscience]

I did.

I told you I’m not going to hold your hand any longer.

If you go through the thread again you might be able to catch up.

[D-fendr]

I did.

Are you referring to the same one with the irrelevant premise? The same one you tried to argue at first?

If so, then it's been tested and failed - the conclusion is true whether this premise is true or false: hence irrelevant.

If it is not the same one, then just post the darn thing and defend it.