[D-fendr]

I did ask him to define "Catholic" and never mentioned the word saved.

Well, the word you used in the post I replied to here was "saved":

You claim all these Catholics are saved?

If you find it too difficult to stay on subject..

It's accurate to say a primary subject of this thread is soteriology - comparing at least two views of salvation. It's on subject to ask what a poster's view is of what it means to be "saved." What is your view on this subject?

[OLD REGGIE]

did ask him to define "Catholic" and never mentioned the word saved.

Well, the word you used in the post I replied to here was "saved":

You claim all these Catholics are saved?

If you find it too difficult to stay on subject..

It's accurate to say a primary subject of this thread is soteriology - comparing at least two views of salvation. It's on subject to ask what a poster's view is of what it means to be "saved." What is your view on this subject?

"Saved" was his word. Not mine. I repeat. Ask him.