That pretty well sums up why argumentative postings from that individual were removed. I'm guessing that the Hindu was not being argumentative but was being inquisitive.
The cyber-world being what it is, one needs to look at the Religion Moderator's illustration of a caucus thread as being like unto a group being in their own church setting. A disruptive person, member or non-member, is going to be found out of bounds.
None of the deleted comments were argumentative.
If you read through the thread and look at posts which responded to the removed ones, you’ll see that.
Besides, I saved a screen shot of the first 50 posts. I just had this feeling.....