Annalex: “The extrascriptural ideas about Bible Alone and Faith Alone were only possible because people trusted Luther’s knowledge of the scripture.”
You: So you disagree with extra scriptural writings? REALLY?
Me: I hope everyone gets a good look at your “reasoning” here. That is a false statement about what Annalex posted, and your own post shows itself false. This is typical of protestants on these RF threads, and a very clear, very typical example of the nature of Catholic/protestant disagreements.
“That is a false statement”
I made no statement.
Perhaps I should have said “counterscriptural” in reference to Sola Fide and “extrascriptural” in reference to Sola Scriptura. Extrascriptural but not counterscriptural would be fine, of course, — we have doctrines like that, — but it is still self-contradictory when “Bible Alone” is the doctrine in question.