Neither one.
Just the usual
Roman Catholic et al rabid clique sort of
KILL THE MESSENGER
effort to turn FR’s Rel Forum into a sub-office of the Vatican.
>>Neither one.<<
I don’t think so.
Take this discussion out of the religion forum and find any poster with a join date in 2006 and no posting history.
On any other forum, that person would be called as a troll or a sockpuppet. I suspect that if that poster were on the other side of the argument, he/she would be called on it here by many people.