It’s refreshing to hear a “let’s change the anthem” piece from someone other than an ardent leftist.
That said, I agree that “America the Beautiful” is a better choice than the current anthem. Key’s poetry is poor and, even if it were good, is tied to the War of 1812 and martial themes. I’m not averse to some war imagery, but it’d be preferable to talk about America’s other fine aspects, too.
Even more clear, IMHO, is that the current anthem is nearly unsingable. “America the Beautiful” is easier on the vocal cords and, in my opinion, the ears too.
Still, I don’t lose any sleep over the current anthem being what it is. When folks get all angry about it, for or against, I think they need to have a lemonade and come watch a ball game with me. Whatever we sing before the game, America is still the same great nation.
At least Key didn't refer to "alabaster cities."
*has to admit that Capcom made rockin' tunes for the two American characters in SFII*
In all seriousness, what's wrong with the current one?