I stand corrected. Thank you all for your input.
Today I heard Mass at Most Holy Redeemer in the Lower East Side of Manhattan, in my pilgrimage to visit all the Catholic Altars in Manhattan. The parishioners there claim it’s the first consecrated church in the City. There are several things of interest therein, including especially a crypt for scores of Redempotrists and a reliquary shrine that boasts 150+ relics, including True Cross and Manger, as well as sizable saintly remains. It is a great pilgrimage church and was recognized formally as such in the sixties during the jubilee of Our Lady of Perpetual Help. Worth a visit and a donation!