In Passover, the Jews were instructed to remember the Passover at each celebration as active participants experiencing it for themselves. The Passover for the Jews was not some historical event they marked with outdoor barbeques, but a real and current event they celebrated in the present tense.
Understood that way, the way it was understood to Christ and the Apostles, makes the RC view more realistic.
Plausible.
Not convincing.
But Christ didn’t really even put it that way.
Inferring, imputing, extrapolating . . .
is NOT the SAME thing as THUS SAYS THE LORD.
When we do that with
“upon this rock”
and end up with a very differen inference . . . then there’s all manner of . . . vigorous . . . protest.