I agree with you that the Holy Spirit is with us - the difference is, I think He resides directly in the Church, and prevents it from error. I don't deny that He may also choose to work outside the Church, but, in accordance with Scripture, He ensures the forces of Satan will not overcome and destroy the Church. Believe me, Catholics absolutely seek and hope for the Holy Spirit - we just believe He has worked through the past two millenia within the Church's bounds.
Sorry if this is a little late, and not directly on point with our earlier conversation. I had about 10 pings to me on this thread, and am trying to play catch-up!
That was probably the Holy Spirit warning you! haha
Okay, so what's the Church? The Catholic organization, or the corporate body of individual believers whether or not they decide to be Catholic?
Back again to 'wherever two or three are gathered in My name...'
I'm really liking this debate by the way.